
SUMMARY: The relationship between moderate and MAGA House Republicans resembles nothing so much as the toxic relationship between an abuser and their victim. The parallels to an abusive partnership are clear: MAGA Republicans are gaslighting moderates and subjecting them to emotional and physical abuse while blaming them for their own aggressive behavior. Moderate House Republicans are represented as the battered spouses, who feel trapped and incapable of leaving the relationship for fear of losing support and electoral success. Ultimately, the author urges readers to support democracy and call their representatives to encourage the end of this unhealthy political association.
KEY WORDS: Toxic relationships, Republican Party, MAGA Republicans, Moderate Republicans, House Republicans, Gaslighting in politics, Battered spouse syndrome, Political abuse, Threats and intimidation, Democracy in danger, Support democracy, Call your representative
Table of Contents:
- The Two Sides of the Toxic Republican Party Relationship
- Get Out of that Toxic Relationship
- Call Your Representative, Script
- Tips for Calling Your Representative
- Contacting Your Representative
I’m having flashbacks to an ugly childhood as I watch the Republican House try to “elect” a Speaker. This isn’t so much a political process as it is a toxic abusive relationship that either side has the strength to end. The MAGA Republicans continue to batter and abuse the moderate Republicans, and the moderate Republicans hang in there taking it in the name of preserving the party, their slim majority, and remaining in elected office.
The Two Sides of the Toxic Republican Party Relationship
MAGA Republicans Just Keep on Gaslighting Moderate Republicans
On the one hand you have the MAGA Republicans who are the sadistic narcissistic psychopathic physical and emotional abusers. They can’t stand the thought of the moderate Republicans leaving them, but they can’t stop themselves from abusing them. They have to threaten them with physical violence. They have to mete out emotional violence. The moderates are forcing them to do it, don’t you see? They don’t want to beat them, scream at them, deprive them of food and water, and call them names. They don’t. They really don’t. It’s not who they are. The moderates are making them by being so bad, by doing things they know they ought not to, by doing things they know will piss them off. The moderates KNOW they can’t control themselves, but they push them, push them, push them until they just can’t help themselves.
The Battered Spouse Syndrome of Moderate Republicans
It’s starting to dawn on the moderates that it doesn’t matter whether MAGA loves them or not, they are going to hit them anyway. However, the moderates don’t quite believe that any other voters besides MAGA voters will love them. They are just so undeserving of real honest votes by independent voters. They have to stay with the MAGAs or no one will ever vote for them again.
They know their independent friends and Democratic siblings are right. It’s a bad relationship. They know MAGA isn’t telling the truth. They keep coming home with money and majorities they can’t explain. They know there is something MAGA is keeping form them, hiding from them…
It’s just when they ask or try to find out, MAGA gets so mad and bad things start happening. They get primaried, the phone calls start, windows get broken.
What can they do now? The few friends they have left, that MAGA allows them to talk to, tell them that there are voters out there… but, how can they be sure? Their friends assure them there is a life outside of elected office, but it’s been so long since they were out of office, they wouldn’t know where to begin. What else could they do? Consult? Lobby? MAGA would just soil their name. They saw what happened to Will Hurd and Jaime Herrera Beutler. They aren’t a Liz Cheney. Really, we expect too much from them.
Besides, it is so good with MAGA… when it’s good. MAGA promises to gerrymander their districts one day, just as soon as they get ahead enough to do so. They promised.
Maybe MAGA is right. Permanent majority doesn’t seem so bad, right? In fact, it is pretty good right? Majority rules is a thing, right? So what, if it is in a single-party pseudo-democracy, it is still a democracy, right? So what if it is only white people voting. At least someone gets to vote, right? That’s a democracy. That counts.
The rest of the world saw what the moderate Republicans couldn’t or wouldn’t: the 2020 election was the opportunity for the moderates to escape their abusive relationship with MAGA. They didn’t have to object to certifying Biden’s election. They could’ve voted to impeach and convict I2I4. It would’ve been so easy… but so scary, too. Did you HEAR those threatening phone calls. Brrr. Who could blame them for voting for Trump after THAT!!1! No one gets into politics because of the strength of their convictions or having courage. That’s just crazy.
What would life be like without a rabid pack of fanatical voters? What would life be like making deals with Democrats? Really, compromising with Democrats? Are you sure? Who would vote for them if they cOmPrOmIsEd? They just can’t.
Now is a Good Time to get out of That Toxic Relationship
America loves second chances and come back kids. Here is the second chance for moderate Republicans to repudiate MAGA. They could insist that the Speaker can’t have voted against certifying the 2020 election or against impeaching I2I4. They could state unequivocally that the Speaker of the House, second in succession, has to support democracy.
Our moderate Republicans are like the abused partner in a relationship. They need support, understanding, and cajoling to get out of it. They need a warm safe secure place to go that is beyond the reach of the MAGA flying monkey squad, where the terrorists that are MAGA cannot find them.
This is where you come in. You have to call their office and assure them that there is life outside of elected office. That they are stuck between a rock and a hard place. They can’t vote for a Speaker that is anti-democratic and authoritarian. Their democracy needs them. This is their time to stand up and be counted.
They need to know that you’ll be there for them even if they do lose a primary or an election.
Call your Representative
The Script for Calling Your MoC
When you call your MoC, you should be prepared just in case someone actually answers or their voice mail isn’t “full.” Use a script. You want to be succinct and clear, and you don’t want to miss anything. Here’s a suggestion:
Hi, my name is [NAME] and Iโm a constituent from [STATE and LOCALITY].
Iโm calling today to tell [REPRESENTATIVE] that our democracy needs them if we are to survive the threat that Donald Trump and his supporters pose to our Constitutional republic. We cannot have a Speaker of the House who does not fully support democracy. That means no one who voted against certifying Biden’s win in 2020, questioned the legitimacy of the 2020 election, or didn’t vote to impeach Trump in 2021 for the insurrection can be Speaker.
Our country and the world are facing multiple crises. We need a House leader who can and will work with moderate Republicans and Democrats to pass the legislation that our country needs right now. It is time for political courage. I expect [REPRESENTATIVE] to have that courage.
Thank you for your time and attention.
IF LEAVING A VOICEMAIL: please leave your full street address to ensure your call is tallied.
Tips for Calling
When you call your representative’s office, please remember the following:
- Only contact YOUR MoC! They only listen to their constituents and dismiss requests from non-constituents. Ask for the aide working on the policy-related issues.
- Be polite! No matter whose office you’re calling. No matter what their positions are. No matter how inflamed you are about the issue — and you should be very passionate — be polite.
- Remember that the people you are talking to are people! So, be nice.
- Call during business hours of the area code their office is in. Typically, that is 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
- Have a script or notes to follow so you don’t forget anything.
- Call with friends, you know like a party.
Contacting Your MoC
Find out how to contact your MoC using these links!
- Common Cause will give you the names, party affiliation, direct phone number, website link, and social media platforms of all of your federal, state, and local elected officials.
- GovTrack gives you the names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, and X-itter handles of your senators and representative. It is pretty straightforward and easy to use. Just plug-in your address. You can also track legislation.
- USA.gov is the official guide to information and services of the US government. This page explains clearly how to contact everyone from the President to your Representative to specific government agencies. Through it you can find the following information about your MoC’s:
- Their phone numbers: DC and state offices
- Their mailing addresses both in DC and their state offices
- Official website with their contact page including email, request a meeting, town hall schedules, and social media
- And, the committees they sit on
- 5 Calls: Sign-up for 5 Calls because they help you contact your member of Congress and keep you abreast of on going issues that are important to you! Now, that is a good deal.
- The Capital Hill Switch Board: (202) 224-3121.
Join Indivisible
Follow the link to Indivisible to find a group near you, their campaigns, events in your neighborhood, and download their handy-dandy booklet!

If you think calling your members of Congress is something every American should be doing, then consider doing one of these:
- SHARE this post with friends, family, acquaintances, or complete strangers on your favorite social media platforms, re-blog on your favorite blog, or just tell someone about it! The Psy of Life isnโt hard to remember until you get in front of the goggling machine again.
- LIKE or SHARE this post using the buttons before and after the post. Remember, you donโt have to have a WordPress account to rate a post, and it really is encouraging to see the stars and likes.
- COMMENT on this post. Let us know if you called and what happened. Let us know why you think the Freedumb Cockus is doing this. There is nothing better than discussing the issues with smart well-informed passionate folks.
- FOLLOW the blog or join our amazingly growing email list:
Image Attribution
This image was generated using Poe’s StableDiffusionXL bot using the prompt, Make a picture of a Republican Party elephant hiding under a table with a squad of raging monkeys with wings on top of the table.







Excellent script, Jack. If there is a critical litmus test for Speaker, it is the 2020 certification vote and the impeachment vote. One thing to add is to not vote for any Speaker candidate who has signed the “Loyalty Pledge” to vote for whoever gets the nomination. They have to be willing to say that unacceptable is unacceptable.
The dynamics of the abusive spouse relationship apply anywhere authoritarian power is invoked.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
Abusive spouses are the original authoritarians. Like I always say, every woman has a man in her life with more power than she does and every man has a woman in his life with less power than he has. So, there’s that.
I worked on this post for two weeks. I finally settled on the abusive spouse analogy. The Republican Party is going for a murder-suicide pact just like the abusers who commit murder-suicide with their families.
The government shutdown that Matt Gaetz achieved by dismissing McCarthy is the point of all of this whether it was “the plan” or just a happy coincidence or some other concatenation that no one has anticipated. Just like the abuser, they’ll just keep pushing buttons and pushing until they all go over the side or someone stands up to them.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think there is a real plan. Trump’s lack of executive functioning is contagious in the MAGA wing. Like their leader, they are going from reaction to reaction in “My way or the highway” mode. It is time for whatever Republicans are left who have their heads screwed on half way straight to clearly choose the highway, just as any abused spouse must choose to get out. Staying for the sake of the kids is bad for everybody.
LikeLiked by 1 person
BTW, another former Trump lawyer just pleaded guilty in Georgia.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jenna Ellis was next on the list. The pundits were predicting that without a trial date looming, you’d get few to no guilty pleas. Ellis, though, was funding her own defense, and most of the folks charged can’t really afford it. After reading Cassidy Hutchinson’s book, you realize the anguish and stress that facing such charges and incumbent legal fees places on people and their families.
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
And, when the odds of getting convicted of multiple felonies are high, the prospect of winding up both broke and in prison becomes very daunting. The Daily podcast from NYT discussed this tonight, and ended wonder why Trump keeps hanging his lawyers out to dry by not funding their defense: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/24/podcasts/the-daily/georgia-lawyers-trump.html
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
The answer to that is that he’s a narcissist. He believes exceptions will be made for him in that he doesn’t have to pay his bills, his debtors will make an exception for him. He believes he’s so smart and special that working for him is all the pay that anyone needs. Who wouldn’t want to go to jail for him? That’s the only question he is capable of asking.
Oh and Mark Meadows really was only a coffee boy for him. He did his own chief-of-staffing.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
Exactly. But, Meadows was a coffee boy keeping sufficiently copious notes to get an immunity deal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
What’s interesting about all of the pleas and now Meadows immunity deal is what we don’t know. We don’t know what kind of deal any of the Georgia pleaers made with Smith, but it seems there surely must be some kind of deal. You really should admit to a crime in one jurisdiction, offer sworn testimony in that case, and then stand trial for the same or similar charges in another jurisdiction. Your testimony is public knowledge. It can and will be used against you in all jurisdictions where the same act is a criminal offense. Powell and Chesebro are both unnamed co-conspirators in Smith’s case. I forget whether Meadows is too, but it would seem likely that he could be charged with a crime after they finish with Trump. Also, every other state where they tried to overturn the election can charge them, namely Arizona and Michigan.
Even though they didn’t plea to the RICO charge itself, you know they’re going to be put on the stand and asked about White House meetings and other communication with everyone else in the RICO case. A lot of that information is going to pertain to whatever charges Smith is going to be bringing against the unnamed and unknown co-conspirators.
Even though the coffee boy was just bring you your diet Coke when the big red button was pressed, doesn’t mean he can’t testify against you about the things he heard you say or other things he asked you to do like burn documents in his office fireplace.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
Whether or not some of these people actually spend much time in jail, they are very likely to spend a good portion of the rest of their life in court.
Apparently, Powell, despite her tearful confession, is still spreading the same old lies on social media.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The recipients of the feculent touch. If we could only smell them now.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think I’ll pass on smelling them and their used Depends.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It could be a new drinking game.
LikeLiked by 1 person
LOL – How about “co-defendants on the wall” instead of “bottles of beer”?
LikeLiked by 1 person
At the rate Fanni Willis is going, that won’t be a very long game.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite so, at least until Jack Smith starts rolling out the indictments of many J6 conspirators, probably after a verdict is in on Trump, or when more cooperating witnesses are needed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
There’s an interesting cross pollination effect going on between the Smith and Willis cases. Whatever is testified to in Willis’ case is useable by Smith as evidence. You know she’s putting her pleaers on the stand and asking them about how they furthered her RICO case against anyone who hasn’t pled, which is essentially confessing to conspiring in Smith’s case in the 6 January insurrection. They may as well make an agreement with Smith.
Meadows, on the other hand, has an immunity deal with Smith, which means he’ll go on the stand BEFORE Willis puts him on trial to testify about what he knew about Trump and the 6 January insurrection conspiracy. That testimony can by used as evidence against him in the RICO case, which means he should make a deal with her, too.
All of the legal pundits are saying look for Giuliani to make the next plea deal with Willis since Ellis’ testimony will be directed at his role in the RICO case and he’s broke and he’s got lots of other cases pending against him.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s something I think a lot of people tend to forget, that all the testimony in these trial will be public record, evidence for any prosecutor who wants to use it, or any civil plaintiffs as well. I suspect that the waiters in the wings are many.
I have to wonder, having seen his mental state at times, whether Giuliani is a very reliable witness, but he does need to make a deal if he can.
LikeLiked by 1 person
There is enough corroborating documentary evidence to make his testimony superfluous, but hearing it from the person who did it can be very convincing to a jury.
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, especially with the jury able to watch the defendant while he hears it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think this is true at all levels, from the family to nation states:
โAll tyrannies rule through fraud and force, but once the fraud is exposed they must rely exclusively on force.โ
โ George Orwell
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
I think that is part of the Great Civics Lesson that we are all living through. How do governments govern, gain legitimacy, or stay in place. There are only two choices: force or decision by the governed. If we give up on democracy, our government will be the one by those who can wield enough force to be in power.
Down that road, madness lays.
Right now Putin is making deals with devils, North Korea, Iran, China, maybe even India. He knows he’s going to have to give up somethings to get what he needs from those governments. China is going to be able exact a high price. Much higher than money.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
And, even if (as we hope) Putin looses in Ukraine, those others will still expect to be paid in some form. Of them all, China is the one he can least afford to stiff.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
Putin has clearly bought and paid for the Republican Party. Way too many of them are doing the heavy lifting and otherwise carrying water for him. What happens when Ukraine turns into such a disaster either through being a prolonged draining stalemate of an out and out loss that he’s tossed from office and unable to pay his “debts” to all of his protectors, enablers, and users?
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
In Russia, the usual fate of leaders who fail to that degree is rather unpleasant. Some few are allowed to retire to a remote daka and shut up.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Make sure the daca is only one or two stories and has few windows.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
And definitely, no balconies.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Putin’s no fool. He’s retiring to a basement with really long tables.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He seems to spend a lot of time there already.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He is a notorious germophobe… Just like Trump.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I may be mistaken, but I think I remember that about Musk too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
this has been going on for at least 20 years now. I used to know our local state GOP assemblyman pretty well some 20 years ago. We both went to the same local restaurant for breakfast once in a while. It was crowded one morning and we got seated together at the same table by accident, started talking. The next time I wen there he was there already and waved me over, and the next thing it had turned into a regular thing. He was a nice guy. He was calm, rational, thoughtful. After a while he started opening up about what it was like being in the state legislature and I found out what a dirty, nasty business it was. The GOP was up to a lot of crap even back then, things he didn’t like, things the voters in his district didn’t like. Didn’t matter. It was either toe the line and vote the way he was told to vote or the next election not only would the party cut off his funding they’d run someone who would toe the line against him. There were threats of cutting his staff, etc. He gave up. His conscious couldn’t handle it any more.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Grouch!
That is some story. I hope you blog about it because it tells the story of the Republican Party. Unfortunately, it has been going on since Reagan. They’ve just been honing their skills and techniques for keeping the party in line.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person