Democrats are famous for pulling hairballs from their cats instead of winning gracefully and with confidence. The 2024 election demonstrated that in full. OM goodness, how could Trump win? Everyone knew what he would do. It was going to be his first term on steroids. No one is surprised.
Without going down the rabbit hole of was the 2024 election rigged, it is cause for questioning the viability of the Democratic Party. Given the performance of Jeffries and Schumer in Congress since the election, you gotta wonder.
With millions participating in the No Kings protests, many people are wondering where the Democratic Party is at? Why didn’t the Democratic Party help organize the protests? How will the Democratic Party capitalize on the political capital and energy that these protests provide them?
I used to think that conservatives needed to organize themselves into a political party as an alternative to Trump, to split the vote and reduce MAGA’s chances of winning. I still think that is the only sane and honest response to Trump. That anti-Trump conservatives are only trying to cash in on Trump criticism on social media and liberal infotainment outlets, tells me that conservatives are not serious about American values and democracy.
Now, though, I have to question whether the Democratic Party is serious about opposing Trump and MAGA. It seems that only in crisis are the Democrats willing to take a stand and only when it is clear that there is no choice. They compromised with the Republicans in the spring to keep the government open… I couldn’t understand what they thought they were going to gain by doing so. Now, they find out that Republicans are not willing to compromise on funding the government. What did they think was going to happen?
Now, they are for Cuomo and against Mamdani in NYC; for Mills and against Platner in Maine (even though, the dude has some baggage). It seems like the Democrats are more for the status quo, meaning systemic racism and exploitative corporate capitalism, than they are for progressive democratic ideals. They seem to have lost their way since FDR, JFK, LBJ, and Obama.
Even if you thought Clinton and Obama had some pretty milquetoast ideas, they had some big ideas. Finding a way to expand healthcare coverage was a big fucking deal to quote Joe Biden. Paying down the deficit and the national debt was a big fucking deal that no Republican has been able to accomplish. Creating and expanding economy is a big fucking deal. Investing in clean energy sources and turning away from fossil fuels is a big fucking deal.
But, we’re not getting anything from the Democratic leadership other than we’re not going to let health insurance premiums increase under the Trump budget. Which is a laudable goal, but they aren’t exactly hit a home run with it.
Our democracy is being threatened like it has never been threatened before. The Republicans want to have a pseudo-democratic single-party white-minority-rule autocracy. White people will still vote. Democrats will field opposition candidates. And, Republicans will win all of the elections.
It will take something more than business as usual to survive this time. When we have ICE agents on the streets of American cities, pulling people kicking and screaming from their beds like it was Kristallnacht and marching them off to be tortured in detention centers, national guard troops “patrolling” the streets of major American cities, and Antifa being declared an international terrorist organization so the FBI, DoJ, and IRS can go after whoever they declare to be a member, we need something more than strongly worded letters and stunts on the floor of Congress.
Perhaps a party fielding true progressives would be part of the solution. I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.
Image Attribution
The image was found on Alternative History using a Creative Commons licensed search.


This interview on today’s Morning Edition at NPR is right in line with this theme.
https://www.npr.org/2025/10/21/nx-s1-5423318/karine-jean-pierre-biden-book-democrats
Then, there’s this item in which MTG sounds downright saneish about what’s going on in the Republican party; https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/10/20/2349548/-MT-Greene-admits-the-GOP-has-no-constructive-plan-and-The-Republican-Party-is-failing?pm_campaign=front_page&pm_source=trending&pm_medium=web
Here in NC, Independent has been the largest voter registration category for years.
We know, from private (off the record) comments by GOP senators who voted to acquit on impeachment, that they would not have done that but for “credible threats” to themselves and families if they voted to convict and remove.
Several of the Founders warned against a two party system, even as they created one.
The long term coalitions in both parties may be cracking.
The core of a true Liberal Progressive Party has to be organized labor. Any political party that has to depend for the ever escalating costs of campaigning on corporations and wealthy oligarchs can’t be that. That is exactly why neither of the two we have can actually represent the real needs of the majority of real people. You work for who pays you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Bob!
I think you’re right about the core of a new liberal-progressive party needing to be labor, luckily, Biden and others have managed to breathe some life back into the labor movement. With Starbucks and Amazon employees organizing and the push for a liveable wage still around, we have the makings of a younger viable labor movement.
We also have some younger, liberal, progressive, smart politicians on the rise. I was very heartened to see the Sanders-AOC tour at this summer. Mamdani is making quite a splash. There are some less well known folks that I follow on my social media that are running for Congressional seats.
Getting election finance reform through is going to be tough. John Roberts may have dug the grave for our democracy between Citizens United, gutting the VRA, and Trump immunity. It really becomes a very steep hill to climb. I don’t think many people realize just how far behind the eight ball we are.
I saw the Karine Jean-Pierre interview. She did well dealing with what I thought were hostile and pushy questions. It was not a softball interview. But, I think she got it wrong about why people go independent and how they choose a candidate to vote for. People go independent because they are disillusioned with the system and are trying to hang on to their political involvement. Independents, however, vote consistently for one party over the other.
I know that for the first time in my politically conscious life, I’m thinking of leaving the Democratic Party. I’m starting to think of them as oligarchy lite. It’s a little depressing after the high of the No Kings marches. I just don’t think that the Democrats are capable of capitalizing and building on this moment.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
I found I was remembering the name of the Democrat home organization in Minnesota for many years, The Farmer Labor Party, original prairie populists. Part of the success of the GOP has been splitting that coalition between farmers and workers. What with Trump bailing out Argentina while they and Brazil are selling soybeans to China instead of our soy farmers who are shut out of the China market by his tariffs, it may be a time that farmers can make common cause with labor. A lot of those folks are facing losing everything if their farm loans are foreclosed. Those loans are short term mortgages, the land, the house, the buildings, the machinery, the animals, everything. Where can another generation of Okies go?
LikeLike
Greetings Jack!
I was gonna say ‘Hi Jack’, but I figure I can’t shout that to you at a station or airport.
Maybe the US left can take a leaf out of the UK left’s book? The Green Party is rallying the left here, growing in numbers and stealing attention away from the likes of Reform and Farage, with a persistent and aggressive social media strategy. They’re using the tools of young people to speak to young people about their plans and ideals, and it seems to be working. Not only that, they are truly left-wing, unlike the Democrats (who have struck me as trying to occupy the centre ground to a fault, a bit like Labour here).
I don’t know how easy it would be for the Democrats to adopt such a policy shift, or if it would be easier for a new party to break the grip of the establishment. I know the US system tends to very-much favour two parties, whereas here we have a bit more variety to choose from.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Ben!
Now, you know why I stick with the old fashioned howdy!
I always wanted the Green Party would be more successful than they were. But, this may be there time. However, the Republicans have so smeared the idea of the Green New Deal from a few years ago, the name Green is probably no longer viable in American politics.
That said, climate change is scaring the bejeezus out of everybody but oil exporters, fossil fuel CEOs, and the politicians they’ve bought, so an environmentally friendly party should have a chance here.
I think Trump is what demonstrates the weakness of our system and the superiority of the parliamentary system. If we had a prime minister, we could have Trump out tomorrow.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like thew idea….;as a matter of fact I was calling for that many years ago….in case you are interested….https://lobotero.com/2010/11/11/how-about-a-bull-moose-party-1/ and https://lobotero.com/2010/11/12/how-about-a-new-bull-moose-party-2/
AS for Clinton…not a fan….he and the DLC did more damage than good….Obama his ideas were excellent but even with a 2 House majority he could get the good stuff done…..Dems are a useless group that we need to rid ourselves of them once and for all.
Peace chuq
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Chuq!
Those were great and prescient posts. I’m glad to have read them.
I feel like I’m late to the party, but it now seems to me that the Democrats are defending the racist and hierarchical status quo just as arduously and vigorously as the Republicans, it is just that they would prefer oligarchy lite and not have as many people die as quickly as they are now. Still, I would rather live in Democratic America than Republican America, but I don’t think they are the agents of change that I always thought they were. I don’t think they are truly trying to build a more perfect union.
If nothing else, the Democrats are hampered by their inability to think or dream big. They play too much small ball, which is what perpetuates the status quo.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree I have seen them diminish themselves over the decades…that is why I have not voted Dem since 1980….money is the culprit I believe….we need the Progressive Party and now. chuq
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Chuq!
Money is definitely the culprit. Dems do some good for the average person. I’d still rather live in pre Dobbs America than post, post-ACA, then pre. I’d also prefer an America that has a functional Congress, which we haven’t had since Obama.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
All you say is spot on….my problem with the Dems is that they had a super majority in the Senate and the House in 2010 and yet only few things were done…..they should have attacked mercilessly. chuq
LikeLiked by 1 person
Howdy Chuq!
The Dems have been too timid since Clinton. That was the capitulation of Dems. We moved to the “center” and turned out backs on our core values. We became Republican lite and it has done about as well as all of the other lite products have.
Huzzah!
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sadly so true….Dems run 3 clicks Left of center and once elected they move 2 clicks Right of center….so sad. chuq
LikeLiked by 1 person
With the events over the past seven days, my sense of urgency has kicked up another notch. There really are no more institutions that can be relied upon to stop him. It is up to us.
Jack
LikeLiked by 1 person
Exactly! And I wonder if we are up to it. chuq
LikeLiked by 1 person