READING TIME: 6 minutes

TL;DR: Sparked by a lively comment-section debate over the 2026 midterms, we explore why American voters repeatedly fail to connect tangible government benefits, like the Inflation Reduction Act subsidies and the Child Tax Credit, to the leaders who delivered them. Rather than blaming voter laziness alone, we examine the cognitive bottlenecks of modern democracy: how cognitive overload, the illusory truth effect, and “knowledge neglect” allow demagogues to exploit mental shortcuts with repeated lies. To prevent another backlash in 2028 and 2030, Democrats must respect human psychology by nominating and backing trustworthy stewards, delivering unmistakable immediate benefits, and relentlessly repeating their achievements.

KEY TERMS: cognitive load, illusory truth effect, knowledge neglect, 2026 midterm elections, Inflation Reduction Act, Child Tax Credit, political communication, misinformation, voter turnout, election 2028

COMMENTS: What do you think the solution to the disinformation and misinformation that Republicans so readily traffic in is? How do we counter the toxicity of lies, dishonesty, and corruption?

The Midterms Wake-Up Call (And the Dots We Still Aren’t Connecting)

An exchange in the comments with friend o’ the blog, Bruce the Desert Rat or is that Dessert Rat? — Hmmm… Could be either or both, I guess — got me to thinking about lessons from the midterms. Most hot takes are based on electorate anger outweighing any good will towards the Democrats. I think that’s right, but it misses the deeper point. Bruce was taking issue with my point that it was the complacency of the American electorate that has caused most of our problems.

The vibe of the midterms is that we didn’t just flush Trump and Republicans, we’re still flushing the toilet two weeks later as we dance around the bathroom singing Hallelujah. But, that point is belied by the 48 or 49 percent turnout that we had. While it is higher than most midterm elections, it is less than the fifty percent turnout in 2018.

That is a real problem because even when our economic lives are on the line in one of the worst economies since World War II, even when our democracy is on the line in one of the greatest threats since the Civil War, less than half of the eligible voters could be bothered to turnout and vote. True there is some Republican voter suppression to blame, but, supposedly, we were prepared for that.

In 2024, we jettisoned one of the most successful presidencies in our history because inflation was too high in the run up to the election, even though it was coming down. Apparently, it was too difficult for voters to comprehend that the seven or eight percent inflation of 2021 was due to the economic disruptions of the #COVID19 pandemic and that Biden had done a great job of engineering a soft landing for our economy. So, when the most prolific liar in the history of humankind came along and said, “What do you have to lose?” many of us, a freaking plurality of us, shrugged our shoulders, thought of inflation, ignored the 6 January Insurrection, and reelected the Grifter-in-Chief.

As a population, we couldn’t connect the dots and ignore our immediate feelings of dissatisfaction. Okay, my thesis on Trump is that all voters with a heaping helping of internalized racism and misogyny are easily seduced by his siren song of dog whistles. The two together were irresistible. As a group, especially, white people, we are too vulnerable to promises of easy quick fixes.

Why was it in election 2024 no one was able to connect the IRA subsidies and tax credits that allowed them to replace their ancient and inefficient appliances (2.34 million families) and the 2.9 million children the Child Tax Credit lifted out of poverty to the Biden administration? Does anyone remember the big fight over the Child Tax Credit expiring? No? No one? That’s because there was none. It was like the child was forgotten in the bath, left to drown, buried in the backyard, and we told everyone they were visiting their grandma while we moved. All of the fighting over the CTC was too internecine and nuanced over extensions, expiry dates, and baselines to be easily understood and followed.

Diagnosis: Why Our Brains Struggle With Modern Governance

It’s tempting to look at the debacle of the 2024 election — discounting Biden’s economic achievements, being confused by Republicans taking credit for public works they voted against, and seeing Trump 1.0 through rose-colored glasses — and conclude that the American electorate is hopelessly lazy, utterly selfish, or woefully oblivious. Okay, on any given day of the week, I could be right there with you, but we’re first and foremost a psychology blog, so we look upon people with a bit of grace and understanding.

While the social medias thrive on us dunking on whoever is sitting around in the rungs below us, if we actually want to right this sinking shipwreck of state, we need to continue winning but with a better turnout than we had in 2026. This cannot be our diagnosis of the American electorate because people aren’t ignoring politics because they don’t care; they’re ignoring it because of cognitive overload. The human brain evolved to avoid hard work so we have shortcuts to solving our problems.

So, let’s look at the psychology of the electorate that the Dems have to work with as we roll into the 2028 election cycle.

The Cognitive Bottleneck

The human brain has a built-in bottleneck. It slows things down and keeps information at manageable levels, all while ensuring the survival of the species. There is only so much information that we can process at the same time. That creates cognitive load when we’ve got too much to consider at once. Add some stress to the mix, and you can’t do much more than what’s in front of you.

Of course, people with two jobs, a spouse, kids, an aging parent, and student loan debt are going to have a difficult time focusing in on the application for a subsidy much less who voted for which version and extension of the Child Tax Credit. All you can manage is that it is there and was gone again.

That kind of distraction makes it easy for an unscrupulous soul like Trump to swoop in with his repeated lies about stolen elections or high inflation or corruption or whatever it is to hijack the narrative, especially when there is an entire echo chamber constructed to help him do just that. Fox News and other rightwing outlets repeat the lies ad nauseam and verbatim, mainstream media outlets feel obligated not only to report them, but sanewash them without much push back, and social media algorithms constantly feed you the most inflammatory material regardless of its accuracy, relying on the reader to distinguish the lie from the disinformation from the truth.

We all know that once something is heard, it takes on the illusion of truthiness. You forget the circumstances that it was heard in and even the disclaimer or contradiction. All you know is that it sounds familiar, and the familiar is a cognitive shortcut to the truth.

Thirty Years of “Truthiness” in Texas

Surely the 2026 election proves the limitations of the rule by narrative approach the Trump takes. Perhaps you remember that way back in the winter of 2021, the Texas utility grid failed and caused at least 246 confirmed deaths and excess deaths of upwards of seven hundred to a thousand Texans. Remember that? That was under the trifecta of Republican rule in Texas. Perhaps you remember July of 2025 when torrential rain caused the Guadalupe River to flood and washed away the BIBLE CAMP, Camp Mystic, killing 25 young girls, two counselors, and the owner of the camp along with dozens of others in its path? Those were good Christian people. Perhaps you remember the 2022 mass shooting at a Uvalde elementary school in which nineteen children and two teachers were shot to death and seventeen others injured while the police stood by quaking in their boots? Perhaps you’re aware of the 159 school districts and 572 schools that can only attend four days a week because Texas would prefer to send its education dollars to wealthy families to use for private schools instead of the people of Texas?

None of these issues happened overnight. They are the product of years of failure. And, finally, finally, they caught up to Abbott and Paxton and all of the other clowns running Texas, but it took thirty years of mismanagement to do it. Thirty years of domination by the Republican Party and blaming Democrats and the mysterious Other.

That’s how effective the cognitive load and delusion of truthiness is. Especially when your audience — the good rural white Christians of Texas — wants to believe it. When they feel they’re insulated from the worst of it and it is hurting the Communities of Color and bad women first and worst.

What do you think happens when the Democratic president and Congress starting in 2028 repairs the mess that the Republicans have made of our economy and the Republicans continue this rule by toxic narrative? How effective will it be? Just look back to W’s election in 2000 and Trump’s in 2016 and 2024.

It’s been extremely effective and it will be again unless the Democrats can find a way to stop it.

Why Knowing Better Doesn’t Save Us: “Knowledge Neglect”

You might think surely we won’t be fooled again, right? Once the wolf springs out of its sheep disguise, we’ll be wise to it and look all of the Trojan sheep in the mouth, right? We’ve been through the wringer with Trump and his lies, so we’re immunized — not that MAGA believes in immunization or anything — against them. Now that we KNOW the truth, we won’t be fooled by cheap talk again, right?

You’d be wrong. We have cognitive psychologist Lisa Fazio of Vanderbilt University to thank for her study of what she calls “knowledge neglect“. She extended the original work on the illusory truth effect, in which participants rate repeated false statements as truer every time they are repeated. Fazio’s contribution was verifying that the participants knew the truth while they were rating the false statements as true. They knew the statements weren’t true, yet they rated them as true anyway. Go figure.

That is the terrifying superpower of the delusion of truthiness. Our brains are so desperate to save energy that familiarity acts faster than retrieving stored facts from memory. Even when you know a politician is lying to you, hearing the lie repeated twenty times on your phone screen makes it feel more plausible than the complicated truth sitting in the back of your head. Worse, when journalists or Democrats repeat the lie just to fact-check it, they give the lie another round of familiarity.

The Treatment Plan for 2028: Working With Human Nature

So, come the 2030 midterms expect the onslaught of disinformation and misinformation to drive the Republican rebound and the eventual return of a Republican demagogue. What can Democrats do to help prevent this delusion from taking hold?

Electing Honest Brokers as Cognitive Delegation

We aren’t going to rewire human evolution before 2028. Voters are still going to have two jobs, aging parents, and limited mental bandwidth. Because ordinary citizens cannot possibly track every legislative baseline, tax credit expiration, or grid regulation, representative democracy is, by design, an act of cognitive delegation.

We hire leaders to deal with the complex details we don’t have time to. And to speak to us with candor when reality turns harsh and there are difficult decisions to make. One inoculation against the delusion of truthiness is electing genuinely honorable, ethical, deeply knowledgeable leaders—folks like James Talarico, Jon Ossoff, and Adam Hamilton. We know these folks are going to be straight with us. It isn’t just a nice moral preference. It is a structural necessity.

Making Good Policy Unmistakable and Unforgettable

The next step is to make the outcomes of their policies and laws unmistakable. We need immediate results that everyone can feel. One good example is restoring the cuts to healthcare that Republicans enacted the last time through. Even if Trump vetoes it, Democrats have to raise unholy heck immediately when he does. We cannot legislate delays in benefits to appease Republicans. In fact, we can’t trust Republicans even a little bit. We have to pass the legislation that we want to see enacted and Republicans can sign on to it if they want.

The last thing is that Democrats have to get better at using social media and earned media to get their messages across. We have to take a page out of Trump’s playbook and repeat endlessly the benefits that we are enacting.

The Open Loop: Psychology Over Shaming

At the end of the day, my friend Bruce and I are both right. Yes, our democracy is teetering because too many citizens check out until the house is actively on fire. Calling that complacency isn’t wrong.

But if we only call voters lazy, we miss the deeper diagnosis. We aren’t dealing with a broken species; we’re dealing with ancient human brains trying to navigate an impossibly complex, hyper-engineered information environment designed to hijack our attention and exploit our shortcuts. You don’t cure cognitive overload by yelling at the patient to concentrate harder. You change the environment, you simplify the signal, and you put trustworthy stewards at the wheel. The 2026 midterms bought us a little breathing room — now comes the real work of figuring out how to keep a democracy alive when human nature itself is part of the equation.

Image Attribution

This image was found on Science Magazine and has a Creative Commons license.


Discover more from The Psy of Life

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.