SUMMARY: As the 2024 election approaches, state-level polling reveals a chaotic and unpredictable political landscape. In Arizona, tight presidential and Senate races suggest a split electorate, while North Carolina’s gubernatorial contest highlights the stark contrasts between candidates. With shifting voter demographics, including increased registrations among younger voters and women, the challenges for pollsters are mounting. Factors like Trump fatigue, abortion rights, and voter suppression efforts complicate predictions. Ultimately, the ability to accurately gauge the electorate’s mood may determine the outcome, making each vote crucial in this dynamic environment.

KEY WORDS: Election 2024, Polling, Arizona, North Carolina, Kamala Harris, Trump, Ruben Gallego, Kari Lake, Josh Stein, Mark Robinson, Ticket Splitting

COMMENT: How do you account for the widespread support for statewide Democratic candidates and the tight presidential candidate in the swing states?

  1. Election 2024: Arizona
    1. The Arizona Presidential Polling
    2. Arizona Senate Race
    3. Arizona Ticket Splitting?
  2. Election 2024: North Carolina
    1. North Carolina Presidential Polling
    2. North Carolina’s Stinking Turd of Gubernatorial Candidate
    3. Deciphering the Polling Difference
  3. Predicting Election 2024
  4. Image Attribution

I keep looking at state level polling and the results seem to me an ass scratcher, and, man, are my fingers stinking!

We’ve grown to rely on polls and take great comfort in even the slightest leads among our favored candidates, but if recent polling is to be believed, it seems like the electorate has lost its damned mind. There are wildly differing levels of support for statewide candidates and the presidential candidates in some of the swing states that seem to defy all reason.

We’re going to look at two of the more egregious states, Arizona and North Carolina. We’ll use Politico’s break down swing state presidential polls and FiveThirtyEight’s analysis of key senate polls and their polling data on North Carolina’s gubernatorial race.

Election 2024: Arizona

The Arizona Presidential Polling

Politico reports these polling averages for the state:

I remember when the Democrats won nearly all the statewide elections in 2022. It felt like a strong repudiation of MAGA, even though most victories came by the thinnest of whiskers. The polling results for 2024 make it sound like 2020 all over again. It’s either candidate’s election to win or lose, and just a few votes would tip it one way or the other.

If the presidential race is this close, then the Senate race must be, too, right?

Arizona Senate Race

The race between Democrat, Ruben Gallego, and Republican, Krai-Krai Lake, shows a much less competitive race. In FiveThirtyEight’s latest polling average, Gallego leads by 6.6%, a trend that’s held since August.

Lake is a female Trump: She still hasn’t conceded her loss in 2022, and she says stupid crazy shit all the time. She was a TV news anchor; he anchored his own reality TV show. They’re so similar, it’s spooky. Are we sure we’ve seen them together?

Arizona Ticket Splitting?

What explains the vast difference in the polling for the two races? Could it be there are Arizonans saying, “I’ll vote for the Old FART, but not Krai-Krai? That’s a bridge too far!” Seriously? That’s what’s happening here?

Or is it that they are that far apart on the issues? Is there some local issue that Lake is known for that alienates Trump voters? Has she proclaimed the Arizona Republican State Party platform to be whatever she says it is rather than what Trump says it is? Is she proclaiming Project 2025 to have been handed down from the burning bush on Mt. Horeb?

Or is it people looking at Gallego saying, “Yeppers, I’ll vote for him! He’s a good ‘un, but Harris? That pinko commie socialist fascist? No way.” What? Could that be it?

Gallego has a seven point lead because Lake is to cray-cray to vote for, but Trump is okay? Or Harris is too radical to vote for, but Gallego is okay?

Neither thing makes sense to me. I figure, one of the sets of polling is way off. Either Gallego doesn’t have the lead we think he does and that race is just as close as Harris-Trump or vice versa.

Election 2024: North Carolina

The punditing pundits are practically stabbing each other in their proverbial backs so they can be the first to breathlessly declare that North Carolina is in play for the first time since Obama took it in 2008.

North Carolina Presidential Polling

The big news is that Harris has pulled even with Trump. Politico reports the polling averages:

  • FiveThirtyEight average: Trump +0.1 (On Sept. 10: Tied)
  • RealClearPolitics average: Trump +0.1 (On Sept. 10: Trump +0.1)
  • Silver Bulletin average: Trump +0.1 (On Sept. 10: Harris +0.1)
  • 2020 result: Trump +1.3

There hasn’t been much change in the past few weeks and the Old FART seems to have lost ground since 2020. In a race that will be decided by thousands if not hundreds of votes, any bit of lost ground could very well mean a lost election.

North Carolina’s Stinking Turd of Gubernatorial Candidate

The other race that is making all kinds of news is the gubernatorial race between Democrat, Josh Stein, and Republican, Mark Robinson, particularly since fifteen-year-old postings Robinson made on porn site message boards have surfaced.

Even before these comments surfaced, Robinson was trailing his Democratic opponent significantly, with FiveThirtyEight reporting a difference between eight and fourteen percent during the month of September.

With Robinson polling as low as 33% in early September, even MAGA Republicans think he’s a bit overboard and unsuited for office. The MAGA rank and vile finds him worse than Maddog Greene, Boobert, and Andy “Buggy” Biggs. I didn’t think that was possible, but it is, and it is just as unlikely as Stein leading Robinson by fourteen points.

Deciphering the Polling Difference

In Arizona, it seems to be a clear case of ticket splitting, but the dynamics in North Carolina seem to be a lot more personal. This may not be so much a case of ticket splitting as it is about the governor’s office having a much bigger and more direct impact on personal lives than the president or even their representatives. 

The loopy antics that MAGA has come to know and love from Trump might be just too much when North Carolinians consider the need for a governor who can effectively protect them from the potential harms of a second Trump term. They need someone who can fight for federal supplies of personal protective equipment, secure federal assistance based on the electoral share Trump received in the state, and find funding for farmers who were driven to bankruptcy by Trump’s tariffs.

Apparently, there are North Carolinians out there saying, “Black jobs,” Okay fine. “She recently turned Black,” Whatever. “If I lose the Jews will be to blame,” I guess. “Where are my Blacks?” Oh yeah, that guy’s there AGAIN! “We’ll lock up all of my critics,” Got that right. “Give me a billion dollars, and we’ll drill drill drill!” Drill, baby, drill! “I’m a Black Nazi!” Now, wait just a cotton picking minute here! That guy’s out! We can’t be associating with that kind of trash.

What could possibly differentiate the two candidates when both are peddling the same racist, antisemitic, misogynist garbage, conspiracy theories, and disinformation?

Could it be that one is white trash and the other is Black? Could it be that there really are North Carolinian MAGA types voting for Stein for governor and Trump because reasons? Or voting for Trump and just skipping the governor’s race?

Stein being ten points ahead of Robinson and Trump one tenth of a point ahead of Harris just doesn’t seem possible! Presumably, all of Stein’s supporters also support Harris, all of Robinson’s supporters, Trump, so where’s the difference coming from?

Predicting Election 2024

Given the shifts within the electorate, predicting the outcome of the 2024 election will be challenging. Factors such as skyrocketing voter registrations—especially among younger voters and women—are at play, alongside declining support for Democrats among Black and Latino voters. Additionally, the dynamics among young white male voters remain uncertain.

Democratic enthusiasm, particularly among Harris supporters, is at a record high, fueled by abortion rights and Trump fatigue. Yet, these positive trends are countered by the voter suppression and nullification efforts of the Republican Party.

As these competing forces intersect, the landscape becomes increasingly complex, making it difficult to ascertain how voters will ultimately cast their ballots.

Because pollsters have to predict turnout to build their samples, they typically use past races as their guide. This time, though, the electorate may have shifted significantly from the 2020 and 2022 elections. They may find it difficult to get a sample that accurately reflects the electorate on November 5, 2024. These wildly differing polling outcomes may be due to just such difficulties. As a result, voters should remain skeptical of the numbers and aware that the political winds can change rapidly, making every vote crucial in this unpredictable landscape.

If you appreciated this discussion of how the polls are showing such different results then consider doing the following:

  • SHARING this post with someone who might enjoy it.
  • LIKING or RATING this post using the buttons above and below the post.
  • COMMENTING on the post with your opinion on the difference in support.
  • FOLLOWING the blog or joining our email list.

Image Attribution

This image was found on The Daily Aus using a DuckDuckGo Creative Commons License search