READING TIME: 6 minutes

TL;DR: The so-called “Never Trump” Republican pundits have found lucrative second acts in liberal media without reckoning with their own roles in building the modern MAGA movement. Figures like Stuart Stevens, Michael Steele, Nicolle Wallace, Sarah Longwell, and Rick Wilson can be placed along a “Continuum of Apologia” with each stop using its own unique psychological defense mechanisms — from cognitive dissonance and intellectualization to ego-syntonic ruthlessness — that allow former GOP operatives to romanticize pre-Trump conservatism and allow themselves to sleep guilt free at night. Democrats should beware! These commentators favor “oligarchy-lite” and remain tactical allies rather than true ideological friends.

KEY TERMS: Never Trumpers, Cognitive Dissonance, Retrospective Distancing, Intellectualization, Ego-Syntonic, The Bulwark, The Lincoln Project, Southern Strategy

COMMENTS: Let me know what you think of my characterization of each of these Never Trumpers and reformed Republicans, especially if you think I’ve treated any of them unfairly.

There is a very large and vibrant left leaning mediaverse out there with a wide variety of points-of-view and politics represented. One of the biggest is the recently rebranded MS NOW and their most popular host is Rachel Maddow, who recently published a book, Department of Fate, about the Department of Justice. Naturally, she’s been making the rounds pimping her book. I heard her recently on Nicolle Wallace’s podcast, The Best People, where Maddow said of Wallace, of all the people at MS NOW, she leans on her the most to get through the tough times like the immediate aftermath of the 2024 election.

I found it to be a very sobering remark. Maddow is perhaps one of the best storytellers of our time. She is famed for meticulous research, blending human interest with historical perspective to produce a unique take on a current event — like her timely book on the Justice Department. Of all the people populating the liberal media, I have the most respect for her.

So, to hear her proclaim such emotional closeness to Nicolle Wallace not only caught my ear, it caused me significant pause. Wallace is one of the many reformed Republicans that can be found performing in liberal media. She has a pleasant affect and is so bland that it is impossible for her to offend. She mixes fawning praise with white middle class outrage so effortlessly that you hardly notice her culpability in creating the modern MAGA movement.

It got me to thinking about the vast world of reformed Republican Never Trumpers who remain in the Republican Party or just outside of it. And the more I thought about it, the more outraged I became. On any given hour, you can listen to one of these reformed Republicans pontificate on the excesses of Trump and prescribe how we should resist him and MAGA. Yet, you almost never hear about how they contributed to the rise of Trump or what they’re doing to stop Trump and MAGA other than grifting off of liberals with their media networks like The Bulwark and The Lincoln Project. As they say, talk is cheap — except for their salaries and expenses.

The Continuum of Apologia

As I see it, this punditing class of yammering heads operates along a Continuum of Apologia. I don’t mean they are apologizing, which would mean expressing regret and trying to make some kind of amends. I mean it in the original Greek sense of making a formal speech in their own defense. They are covering their own asses for their role in the Republican Party’s descent into racialized divisive politics and anti-democratic authoritarian proclivities.

That Continuum of Apologia runs from Stuart Stevens (It Was All A Lie), Max Boot (The Corrosion of Conservatism), and Tim Miller (Why We Did It) at one end, down to Rick Wilson (Everything Trump Touches Dies) at the other, with Sarah Longwell, Nicolle Wallace, and Michael Steele scattered in between. Let’s take a look at each, shall we?

The Confessional Wing: Stevens, Boot, and Miller

In their respective books, Stevens, Boot, and Miller each discuss the toxic elements of the Republican Party that have been growing since Goldwater and that Reagan lit on fire. They detail the deliberate weaponization of racism in the Southern Strategy to attract aggrieved white voters, the use of token Black Republicans (looking at you Michael Steele) to assuage suburban white women’s sensibilities, and the deployment of inflammatory divisive social issues to keep the base seething with anger and vitriol. They attacked the government itself as being illegitimate while transferring the wealth of the middle class to the one percent as quickly as they could.

They at least owned what we could all plainly see once Trump ascended to the top of the dung heap that is the Republican Party.

Selective Amnesia and “Lost Cause” Nostalgia: Steele and Wallace

Next on the continuum are Michael Steele and Nicolle Wallace. Both detest Trump, yet both long for the “good old days” of Reagan, Poppy, and W — insisting that that brand of Republicanism was noble and virtuous. “This is my house. I’ve been here for 50 years. When did you show up [with] all your nonsense and foolishness?” Steele demanded in self-righteous indignation on his MS NOW show The Weeknight recently. Fifty years, really? Fifty years ago was 1976, when Gerald Ford cast us onto this most fucked-up timeline by pardoning Nixon and failing to contain the wild inflation Nixon ignited through his political manipulation of interest rates. Where was Steele’s objection to the party’s endless advocacy of “states’ rights,” “law and order,” and the War on Drugs — all of them thinly veiled dog whistles dating back to Reagan kicking off his 1980 campaign in Neshoba County, Mississippi, where sixteen years earlier three civil rights workers were brutally murdered?

Nicolle Wallace plays the exact same game of selective amnesia, except with an affable smile. As George W. Bush’s White House Communications Director, Wallace wasn’t an innocent bystander — she was the chief publicist for an administration that lied us into an illegal war and drove the economy straight into the Great Recession. Yet today she gushes over the genteel niceness of W, the “compassionate conservative.” Nice compassion you got there. God help us if there’s any more where that came from.

Even more revealing is how Wallace handles her direct role as a senior adviser on John McCain’s 2008 campaign, where she helped manage and spin the rollout of Sarah Palin — the prototype for Trump’s know-nothing populism. Wallace has offered the self-absolving observation that “the party bears some responsibility” for Palin, as if Palin descended from the Alaskan skies like an act of God rather than a vetted political weapon Wallace herself was paid to sell to the American public. When Wallace talks about Palin today, she laughs it off like she was stuck babysitting a chaotic reality-TV star instead of reckoning with why she didn’t resign on the spot rather than inflict someone so dangerously unqualified on the nation.

Both Steele and Wallace gloss over Newt Gingrich’s mid-1990s “permanent majority” rhetoric preaching that Democrats weren’t opponents, they were the enemy. Neither mentions Mitch McConnell’s anti-democratic edict that “winners make policy, losers go home” — the same McConnell who refused to even acknowledge Merrick Garland’s existence after vowing to make Barack Obama a one-term president by obstructing every legislative initiative in the middle of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression.

They are both displaying textbook cognitive dissonance paired with retrospective distancing. To admit that their beloved “50-year house” was built on racial resentment and scorched-earth obstruction would destroy their moral self-image. This level of cognitive dissonance is necessary in order to continue believing in the lost cause of the noble Republican Party of smaller government and low taxes. Their selective nostalgia for the fairytale of a kinder gentler racist anti-democratic conservatism allows them to sleep at night without admitting that they were the marketing department that built MAGA.

The Detached Anthropologist: Sarah Longwell

Further down the continuum is Sarah Longwell, whose defense mechanism of choice is clinical intellectualization. Instead of owning her years as a GOP operative who helped normalize the right-wing ecosystem, Longwell has reinvented herself as the detached anthropologist of American politics. She spends her days running focus groups and extracting qualitative data from voters left and right to dissect the psyche of the nation — conveniently treating MAGA voters like fascinating lab specimens while completely ignoring her own motivations and direct contributions to creating the madness she now studies under glass.

The Ego-Syntonic Knife-Fighter: Rick Wilson

And then, sitting at the far, unrepentant end of the continuum, is Rick Wilson. While Wallace and Steele are dangerous because of their total lack of self-insight, Wilson is the most despicable because of the sheer glee he takes in politics as blood sport. His book, Everything Trump Touches Dies, isn’t a mea culpa — it’s a 336-page apologia arguing that the pre-2016 Republican machine was a glorious engine of freedom until Donald Trump crashed it into a ditch.

In psychology, Wilson’s posture isn’t cognitive dissonance at all; it’s ego-syntonic. He experiences zero inner conflict over his 30-year career as a slash-and-burn GOP ad-maker — including his infamous 2002 campaign ads questioning the patriotism of triple-amputee Vietnam veteran Max Cleland (which is why we can no longer use his coinage of #ETTD. Instead, we should use my coinage of The Feculent Touch! Really. It is much cooler) — because ruthless character assassination aligns completely with who he thinks he is. He doesn’t regret coarsening our political discourse; he openly boasts on air about wanting to do more of it, just on behalf of a new set of clients. Given half the chance, he would Max Cleland another Democratic candidate the moment the coast is clear.

The Scott Evil Syndrome and the “Oligarchy-Lite” Trap

Essentially, Rick Wilson is Scott Evil, Dr. Evil’s son in the Austin Powers movies. Scott doesn’t sit in the underground volcano lair objecting to his father’s mad, murderous schemes on moral grounds; he just thinks the theatrics are tacky and inefficient. In the famous scene where Dr. Evil lowers Austin Powers toward a tank of mutated, ill-tempered sea bass and walks out of the room, Scott loses his mind — not because murder is wrong, but because it’s bad execution: “I have a gun in my room! You give me five seconds, I’ll get it, I’ll come back down here, BOOM, I’ll blow their brains out!”

That is the Never Trump consultant class in a nutshell. They didn’t object to the core mission of the volcano lair—the voter suppression, the trickle-down wealth extraction, the judicial packing, the racial dog whistles. They only threw up their hands when Trump swapped out the quiet, professional hit for the loud, embarrassing circus act, when Trump said the quiet part out loud and made it so none of them could deny what they were up to. When facing themselves in the mirror, they all made their choices in how to cope with the dissonance it created in their souls.

These people all willingly and knowingly embraced the Kool-Aid of oligarchy. They just preferred oligarchy-lite instead of the bloating that came with the full-calorie oligarchy. Whether they know it or not, they would be seduced right back into the same trickle down economics, racist dog whistles, anti-democratic structural inequalities that produced Trump in the first place. They were comfortable there. It was normal for them. They’d go back in a heartbeat if Trump hadn’t sullied it.

Democrats and liberals should not forget the role that each of these folks have played in getting us to where we are today. Even if they go through the four parts of an apology: (1) accepting responsibility for the harm they’ve caused, (2) expressing sincere remorse for the damage they’ve inflicted on the world, (3) a sincere commitment to avoid doing it again, and (4) making it up to the rest of us, we should remember they are at best tactical allies, not genuine friends.

Image Attribution

This image was found on PICRYL and has a Creative Commons license.


Discover more from The Psy of Life

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.